| 1860 – 1862 William Clark |  |
| 1863 John Wood | |
| 1864 – 1866 William Clark | |
| 1867 J. B. Box | |
| 1868 – 1871 J. V. Johnson | |
| 1872 William Clark | |
| 1873 J. V. Johnson | |
| 1874 J. P. L. Maxey | |
| 1875 – 1878 J. P. Box | |
| 1879 J. P. L. Maxey | |
| 1880 J. V. Johnson | |
| 1881 – 1884 John Letts | |
| 1885 J. P. L. Maxey | |
| 1886 John Letts | |
| 1887 E. M. Lumpkin | |
| 1888 J. S. Price | |
| 1889 – 1891 E. T. Shelton | |
| 1892 S. A. Beauchamp | |
| 1893 E. T. Shelton | |
| 1894 Elmer Bumpus | |
| 1895 J. B. Dotson | |
| 1896 John Youngblood | |
| 1897 – 1898 N. Allee | |
| 1899 – 1908 R. L. Hood |  |
| 1909 W. T. Church | |
| 1910 Clifford Cox | |
| 1911 J. S. Price | |
| 1912 – 1915 A. K. McGraw | |
| 1916 – 1917 C. A. Stephens | |
| 1918 – 1919 C. E. Humphrey | |
| 1920 – 1921 F. D. Cook |  |
| 1922 C. T. D. Arnold | |
| 1923 – none | |
| 1924 – 1927 R. L. Hood | |
| 1928 F. A. Searey | |
| 1929 – 1930 H. W. Allee | |
| 1931 – 1936 H. W. Gadd |  |
| 1937 – 1938 G. L. Newkirk |  |
| 1939 – 1941 Gordon Carpenter |  |
| 1942 W. S. Montgomery |  |
| 1943 Stewart McDaniel |  |
| 1944 – 1945 James Thomas |  |
| 1946 – 1947 Dallas Kilmer | |
| 1948 – 1949 Thomas Payne |  |
| 1950 – 1953 A. W. Duncan |  |
| 1954 – 1957 Fred Pulliam |  |
| 1958 – 1959 Gordon Logan |  |
| 1960 – 1967 Richard Clark |  |
| 1968 Burrel Jones |  |
| 1969 | |
| 1970 – 1971 Howard James |  |
| 1972 | |
| 1973 Fred Pulliam (Int) | |
| 1974 – 1978 David Ford | |
| 1979 Evan Wall | |
| 1980 – 1993 Larry Hendrickson |  |
| 1994 Nelson Duke (Int) | |
| 1994 John Shaw | |
| 1996 – 2000 David Scudder |  |
| 2000 – 2006 John Gorham |  |
| 2007 – 2013 David Phelps |  |
| 2013 – 2018 Steven Bickel |  |
| 2019 – 2020 Edgar Engle |  |
| 2020 – Shawn Higgins |
